Calculate Minimum Energy for 10% ROI and Investment Approval
You are evaluating whether a proposed renewable energy plant can achieve a 10% annual ROI based on annual operating profit before taxes and depreciation.
Given:
-
Selling price:
$40/kWh
-
Variable cost:
$20/kWh
-
Fixed operating cost:
$25 million/year
-
Land lease:
$5 million/month
, or
$60 million/year
-
Maximum annual capacity:
8.8 million kWh/year
-
Initial investment:
$400 million
-
Target ROI:
10%
per year on initial investment
Constraints & Assumptions
-
Use the annual capacity of
8.8 million kWh/year
for feasibility.
-
Treat ROI as annual operating profit divided by initial investment.
-
Ignore taxes, depreciation, financing, and inflation.
-
Show units and intermediate calculations.
Clarifying Questions to Ask
-
Is the selling price really per kWh, or should it be per MWh?
-
Are fixed costs annual and fully allocated to this plant?
-
Is maximum capacity physically achievable every year?
Part 1 - Required Energy
What is the minimum annual energy the plant must generate and sell to achieve a 10% ROI?
What This Part Should Cover
-
Required annual profit from the target ROI.
-
Contribution margin per kWh.
-
Total fixed costs.
-
Solving
profit = margin * Q - fixed_costs
for
Q
.
Part 2 - Capacity Feasibility
Can the plant achieve the target ROI given the maximum annual capacity?
What This Part Should Cover
-
Compare required annual energy with max capacity.
-
Compute operating profit at maximum capacity.
-
Interpret whether the investment should be approved under the assumptions.
Part 3 - Approval Levers
If the plant cannot meet the target, what levers could make it feasible?
What This Part Should Cover
-
Higher price, lower variable cost, lower fixed cost, lower capex, subsidies, credits, capacity increase, or alternative technology.
-
Practicality and risk of each lever.
What a Strong Answer Covers
A strong answer calculates the required output cleanly, checks the capacity constraint, and turns the math into an investment recommendation with sensitivity levers.
Follow-up Questions
-
How would the answer change if price and variable cost were per MWh?
-
What selling price would be required at maximum capacity?
-
What is the largest fixed cost the project can support?