Compare Redux with Modern Front-End State/Data Management and Propose an End-to-End Strategy
Context
You are building a React single-page application that:
-
Consumes multiple REST APIs
-
Must support offline viewing, pagination, optimistic updates, and error retries
-
Needs a clear separation between local UI state and server-fetched state
-
Currently uses Redux (classic or Redux Toolkit) and seeks an incremental migration path
Task
-
Compare Redux/Redux Toolkit with more modern approaches: React Query (TanStack Query) or SWR, Zustand or Recoil or MobX, and native Context.
-
Propose an end-to-end strategy for managing local UI state and server cache for this app.
-
Discuss trade-offs and decisions across:
-
Where to keep server state vs. local state
-
Caching and invalidation patterns (including pagination)
-
Performance (render churn, selectors, memoization)
-
Error handling and retry strategies
-
Testing and type safety
-
An incremental migration plan from an existing Redux codebase