Derive Coefficient and Covariance in Regression Analysis
This statistics prompt tests correlation constraints, regression slope relationships, covariance of order statistics, and change-of-variables reasoning.
Constraints & Assumptions
-
Assume finite second moments for correlation and regression questions.
-
Assume simple linear regression with an intercept where slopes are discussed.
-
For the uniform order-statistic question, let
X
and
Y
be independent
Uniform(0,1)
.
-
State any monotonicity and differentiability assumptions for the change-of-variables result.
Clarifying Questions to Ask
-
Are
X
,
Y
, and
Z
standardized, or are we discussing correlations only?
-
Is
R^2
from simple linear regression with one predictor?
-
Should the final answers be formulas, derivations, or numerical values?
Part 1 - Equicorrelation Constraint
For three random variables X, Y, and Z with identical pairwise correlations rho, what is the smallest possible value of rho?
What This Part Should Cover
-
Equicorrelation matrix.
-
Positive semidefinite constraint.
-
Minimum
rho = -1/2
.
Part 2 - Reverse Regression Slope
In simple linear regression of Y on X, you know R^2 and the slope coefficient. Derive the slope coefficient from regressing X on Y.
What This Part Should Cover
-
Relationship between slopes, correlation, and standard deviations.
-
Product of the two simple-regression slopes equals
R^2
.
-
Edge case when the slope and
R^2
are zero.
Part 3 - Covariance of Maximum and Minimum
Let X and Y be i.i.d. Uniform(0,1). Compute the covariance between max(X,Y) and min(X,Y).
What This Part Should Cover
-
Expectations of minimum and maximum.
-
Identity
min(X,Y) * max(X,Y) = XY
.
-
Final covariance
1/36
.
Part 4 - Change of Variables
Suppose Y = g(X), where g is monotone. What is the density of Y in terms of the density of X?
What This Part Should Cover
-
Inverse transformation.
-
Absolute derivative/Jacobian term.
-
Correct handling of increasing versus decreasing transformations.
What a Strong Answer Covers
A strong answer gives clean derivations, states assumptions, and recognizes the matrix, regression, order-statistic, and transformation tools needed for each part.
Follow-up Questions
-
How does the minimum equicorrelation generalize to
n
variables?
-
What if
R^2
is known but the slope sign is not?
-
How would the covariance change for more than two uniform variables?