How would you manage precision/recall for fraud detection?
Overview
This question evaluates a candidate's competency in applied machine learning for fraud detection, covering model performance measurement, thresholding, monitoring, and operational decisioning in a production setting; it is categorized under Machine Learning with a fraud-detection domain focus and tests both conceptual understanding and practical application for a data scientist role. It is commonly asked to probe the ability to select and balance a primary metric versus diagnostic metrics and operational guardrails, reason about cost asymmetry, label delay and distribution shift, and weigh trade-offs between product/user experience and fraud loss.
Scenario
You own (or significantly contribute to) a production fraud detection system that flags transactions/users as fraud vs legit.
- The model outputs a fraud probability score .
- A decision threshold determines whether to block , step-up verify , or send to manual review .
- Labels may be delayed (chargebacks) and the data is highly imbalanced .
Questions
- Precision/Recall management: What concrete methods have you used (or would you use) to measure, manage, and optimize precision and recall in a real fraud system?
- False positives: How would you diagnose and reduce false positives (legit users being flagged) without letting fraud through?
- Sudden fraud spike: If you suddenly observe many more fraud cases than usual, what changes would you make (model, thresholding, monitoring, operations), and how would you validate them quickly?
- Specific fraud pattern: If fraud shows a very specific/pattern (e.g., a new attack vector with clear signatures), what would you do—rules, model features, segmentation, retraining—and how would you prevent overfitting to a short-lived pattern?
Please be explicit about:
- The primary metric vs diagnostic metrics vs guardrails you would use.
- How you handle cost asymmetry (FP vs FN), label delay , and distribution shift/adversarial adaptation .
- The trade-off between product/user experience and fraud loss .
Solution
Login required