Behavioral: recent critical feedback you received and how you acted on it

Quick Overview

A behavioral question for product manager candidates at GitHub about the most recent critical feedback they received. It tests self-awareness and coachability: naming real feedback, handling the first reaction, making concrete changes in how they work and showing evidence that the change stuck.

Behavioral: recent critical feedback you received and how you acted on it

Company: GitHub

Role: Product Manager

Category: Behavioral & Leadership

Difficulty: medium

Interview Round: Other

In a product manager interview at GitHub, you are asked to share the latest piece of critical feedback you received at work: what it was and what you did about it. ```hint Recent and real beats polished Pick feedback that genuinely stung and that led to a change someone else could see, rather than a strength in disguise, and be ready to say what you thought when you first heard it. ``` ### Clarifying Questions - Does "most recent" mean the latest feedback of any size, or the most recent significant piece? - Does feedback from a peer, a direct report or a customer count, or should it come from a manager? - May I describe feedback I partly disagreed with, or only feedback I fully accepted? ### What a Strong Answer Covers - A specific, genuinely critical piece of recent feedback, with who gave it and in what setting - An honest account of the first reaction and how the candidate moved from defensiveness to understanding - Concrete changes in behavior rather than intentions - Evidence that the change worked, ideally confirmed by the person who gave the feedback - Awareness of the underlying pattern and how the candidate seeks feedback now ### Follow-up Questions - Was there any part of that feedback you disagreed with, and how did you handle it? - How do you get candid feedback from engineers or peers who do not report to you? - Tell me about a piece of hard feedback you recently gave someone else.

Overview: A behavioral question for product manager candidates at GitHub about the most recent critical feedback they received. It tests self-awareness and coachability: naming real feedback, handling the first reaction, making concrete changes in how they work and showing evidence that the change stuck.

GitHub logo
GitHub
Apr 6, 2025
mediumProduct ManagerOtherBehavioral & Leadership
1
0

In a product manager interview at GitHub, you are asked to share the latest piece of critical feedback you received at work: what it was and what you did about it.

Clarifying Questions Guidance

  • Does "most recent" mean the latest feedback of any size, or the most recent significant piece?
  • Does feedback from a peer, a direct report or a customer count, or should it come from a manager?
  • May I describe feedback I partly disagreed with, or only feedback I fully accepted?

What a Strong Answer Covers Guidance

  • A specific, genuinely critical piece of recent feedback, with who gave it and in what setting
  • An honest account of the first reaction and how the candidate moved from defensiveness to understanding
  • Concrete changes in behavior rather than intentions
  • Evidence that the change worked, ideally confirmed by the person who gave the feedback
  • Awareness of the underlying pattern and how the candidate seeks feedback now

Follow-up Questions Guidance

  • Was there any part of that feedback you disagreed with, and how did you handle it?
  • How do you get candid feedback from engineers or peers who do not report to you?
  • Tell me about a piece of hard feedback you recently gave someone else.