Behavioral: recent critical feedback you received and how you acted on it
Quick Overview
A behavioral question for product manager candidates at GitHub about the most recent critical feedback they received. It tests self-awareness and coachability: naming real feedback, handling the first reaction, making concrete changes in how they work and showing evidence that the change stuck.
Behavioral: recent critical feedback you received and how you acted on it
Company: GitHub
Role: Product Manager
Category: Behavioral & Leadership
Difficulty: medium
Interview Round: Other
In a product manager interview at GitHub, you are asked to share the latest piece of critical feedback you received at work: what it was and what you did about it.
```hint Recent and real beats polished
Pick feedback that genuinely stung and that led to a change someone else could see, rather than a strength in disguise, and be ready to say what you thought when you first heard it.
```
### Clarifying Questions
- Does "most recent" mean the latest feedback of any size, or the most recent significant piece?
- Does feedback from a peer, a direct report or a customer count, or should it come from a manager?
- May I describe feedback I partly disagreed with, or only feedback I fully accepted?
### What a Strong Answer Covers
- A specific, genuinely critical piece of recent feedback, with who gave it and in what setting
- An honest account of the first reaction and how the candidate moved from defensiveness to understanding
- Concrete changes in behavior rather than intentions
- Evidence that the change worked, ideally confirmed by the person who gave the feedback
- Awareness of the underlying pattern and how the candidate seeks feedback now
### Follow-up Questions
- Was there any part of that feedback you disagreed with, and how did you handle it?
- How do you get candid feedback from engineers or peers who do not report to you?
- Tell me about a piece of hard feedback you recently gave someone else.
Overview: A behavioral question for product manager candidates at GitHub about the most recent critical feedback they received. It tests self-awareness and coachability: naming real feedback, handling the first reaction, making concrete changes in how they work and showing evidence that the change stuck.
Behavioral: recent critical feedback you received and how you acted on it
GitHub
Apr 6, 2025
mediumProduct ManagerOtherBehavioral & Leadership
1
0
In a product manager interview at GitHub, you are asked to share the latest piece of critical feedback you received at work: what it was and what you did about it.
Clarifying Questions Guidance
Does "most recent" mean the latest feedback of any size, or the most recent significant piece?
Does feedback from a peer, a direct report or a customer count, or should it come from a manager?
May I describe feedback I partly disagreed with, or only feedback I fully accepted?
What a Strong Answer Covers Guidance
A specific, genuinely critical piece of recent feedback, with who gave it and in what setting
An honest account of the first reaction and how the candidate moved from defensiveness to understanding
Concrete changes in behavior rather than intentions
Evidence that the change worked, ideally confirmed by the person who gave the feedback
Awareness of the underlying pattern and how the candidate seeks feedback now
Follow-up Questions Guidance
Was there any part of that feedback you disagreed with, and how did you handle it?
How do you get candid feedback from engineers or peers who do not report to you?
Tell me about a piece of hard feedback you recently gave someone else.