Compare Paxos and Raft

Q: Compare Paxos and Raft

This question evaluates understanding of distributed consensus protocols, replicated logs, linearizability, fault tolerance, and operational concerns such as leader election, quorum semantics, log replication, membership changes, and failure recovery.

Q: How do I approach System Design interview questions?

System Design questions require understanding of core concepts and practice. PracHub provides solutions with explanations to help you master system design interviews.

Question

Consensus over a Replicated Log: Paxos vs. Raft

Context

You are designing a fault-tolerant replicated log to back a stateful service (e.g., a key-value store). The system must be linearizable, tolerate crash-recovery failures and network partitions, and run on 2f+1 nodes to survive up to f failures.

Tasks

Explain how Paxos (specifically Multi-Paxos) and Raft achieve consensus over a replicated log.
Compare the two across:
- Leader election
- Quorum requirements
- Log replication mechanics
- Membership changes (cluster reconfiguration)
- Behavior under network partitions
Walk through failure scenarios and recovery:
- Leader crash
- Message delays/reordering
- Disk loss
Given goals of operational simplicity and debuggability, choose one for a new service and justify the trade-offs.

Compare Paxos and Raft

Consensus over a Replicated Log: Paxos vs. Raft

Context

Tasks

Solution

Comments (0)

Compare Paxos and Raft

Overview

Consensus over a Replicated Log: Paxos vs. Raft

Context

Tasks

Solution

Comments (0)