Estimate expected comparisons in a BST

Quick Overview

Estimate expected comparisons in a BST evaluates algorithm design, data structures, correctness, complexity, edge cases, and implementation details in a realistic interview setting. A strong answer states assumptions, handles edge cases, explains trade-offs, and shows how to validate the result clearly.

Estimate expected comparisons in a BST

Company: Optiver

Role: Software Engineer

Category: Coding & Algorithms

Difficulty: medium

Interview Round: Take-home Project

In a particular binary search tree, finding node A takes 1 comparison and finding node D takes 3 comparisons. What is the expected number of comparisons to find a uniformly random node in this tree? State assumptions and justify your estimate.

Quick Answer: Estimate expected comparisons in a BST evaluates algorithm design, data structures, correctness, complexity, edge cases, and implementation details in a realistic interview setting. A strong answer states assumptions, handles edge cases, explains trade-offs, and shows how to validate the result clearly.

Solution

# Solution Alignment The prompt asks for an implementation-level answer. The safest way to present it is to define the state, maintain clear invariants, then walk through complexity and tests. ## Problem Restatement In a particular binary search tree, finding node A takes 1 comparison and finding node D takes 3 comparisons. What is the expected number of comparisons to find a uniformly random node in this tree? State assumptions and justify your estimate. ## Recommended Approach Choose traversal based on the required view or aggregate. DFS is natural for subtree computations and reconstruction; BFS is natural for level order or side views. Keep per-depth or per-position state when the output depends on columns, rows, or depths. ## Correctness The implementation should maintain an invariant after each loop or operation that directly matches the problem statement. At termination, that invariant implies the returned value has considered every valid candidate exactly once, or has preserved the required data-structure state after every API call. ## Complexity Most tree traversals are O(n) time and O(h) recursion stack for DFS or O(w) queue space for BFS, where h is height and w is maximum width. ## Edge Cases and Tests Empty tree, one node, skewed tree, duplicate values when reconstruction assumes uniqueness, deep recursion, and tie-breaking for same row/column nodes.
|Home/Coding & Algorithms/Optiver
Optiver logo
Optiver
Jul 17, 2025, 12:00 AM
mediumSoftware EngineerTake-home ProjectCoding & Algorithms
17
0

Estimate expected comparisons in a BST

In a particular binary search tree, finding node A takes 1 comparison and finding node D takes 3 comparisons. What is the expected number of comparisons to find a uniformly random node in this tree? State assumptions and justify your estimate.

Clarifying Questions to Ask Guidance

  • Clarify input sizes, value ranges, mutability, return format, and tie-breaking.
  • State the target time and space complexity before coding.
  • Call out edge cases such as empty inputs, duplicates, invalid values, overflow, and boundary sizes.

What a Strong Answer Covers Guidance

  • A clear algorithm with the right data structures and enough pseudocode or code-level detail to implement it.
  • A correctness argument that explains why the algorithm covers all required cases.
  • Time and space complexity, plus at least one alternative approach when relevant.
  • Focused tests for normal cases, edge cases, and failure modes.

Follow-up Questions Guidance

  • How would the approach change if the input were streaming or too large for memory?
  • What invariants would you assert in production code?
  • Which tests would catch off-by-one, duplicate, or tie-breaking bugs?

Submit Your Answer to Earn 20XP

Sign in to leave a comment

Loading comments...