Fermi estimate: balls required to pack a room measuring 16 by 16 feet

Quick Overview

An estimation question that asks how many balls would fill a room measuring 16 by 16 feet. It tests clarifying ball type and ceiling height, setting up a volume equation, allowing for the gaps between spheres, converting units correctly and sanity-checking the result with a second method.

Fermi estimate: balls required to pack a room measuring 16 by 16 feet

Company: Google

Role: Product Manager

Category: Product / Decision Making

Difficulty: medium

Interview Round: Other

Estimate how many balls it would take to fill a room that measures 16 feet by 16 feet. Talk through how you structure the estimate, state each assumption as you make it, and finish with a number and a range. ```hint Mind the gaps Round balls cannot fill a space solid. Decide how you will account for the empty space between them, and keep the room and the ball in the same units. ``` ### Clarifying Questions - What kind of ball: a ping pong ball, a tennis ball, a basketball, or a mix of sizes? - Is 16 by 16 feet the floor, and if so, how high is the ceiling? - Is the room empty, and should the balls reach all the way to the ceiling? - Are the balls poured in loosely or stacked by hand, and can they be squeezed? ### What a Strong Answer Covers - Ball type and room height settled with the interviewer, or stated as explicit assumptions, before any arithmetic - An equation linking the room's volume, one ball's volume and the share of the room the balls can actually occupy - A justified allowance for the gaps between spheres - Unit conversions and arithmetic that are correct and easy to follow - A sanity check by a second method, a final range, and how the answer moves with ball size or room height ### Follow-up Questions - If the ball's diameter were 10% larger, roughly how much would your answer change, and why is the effect so large? - How would a door, furniture or a sloped ceiling change your method? - How could you test your packing assumption quickly with everyday objects?

Overview: An estimation question that asks how many balls would fill a room measuring 16 by 16 feet. It tests clarifying ball type and ceiling height, setting up a volume equation, allowing for the gaps between spheres, converting units correctly and sanity-checking the result with a second method.

Google logo
Google
Dec 6, 2023
mediumProduct ManagerOtherProduct / Decision Making
0
0

Estimate how many balls it would take to fill a room that measures 16 feet by 16 feet. Talk through how you structure the estimate, state each assumption as you make it, and finish with a number and a range.

Clarifying Questions Guidance

  • What kind of ball: a ping pong ball, a tennis ball, a basketball, or a mix of sizes?
  • Is 16 by 16 feet the floor, and if so, how high is the ceiling?
  • Is the room empty, and should the balls reach all the way to the ceiling?
  • Are the balls poured in loosely or stacked by hand, and can they be squeezed?

What a Strong Answer Covers Guidance

  • Ball type and room height settled with the interviewer, or stated as explicit assumptions, before any arithmetic
  • An equation linking the room's volume, one ball's volume and the share of the room the balls can actually occupy
  • A justified allowance for the gaps between spheres
  • Unit conversions and arithmetic that are correct and easy to follow
  • A sanity check by a second method, a final range, and how the answer moves with ball size or room height

Follow-up Questions Guidance

  • If the ball's diameter were 10% larger, roughly how much would your answer change, and why is the effect so large?
  • How would a door, furniture or a sloped ceiling change your method?
  • How could you test your packing assumption quickly with everyday objects?