Handling a Disagreement and Owning a Project Failure With Senior-Level Scope
Company: DoorDash
Role: Software Engineer
Category: Behavioral & Leadership
Difficulty: medium
Interview Round: Onsite
For a senior software engineer role, the hiring manager round is behavioral and includes questions such as the two below. The candidate's own takeaway was that this round rewards stories about high-impact projects that show the scope expected of a senior engineer.
### Clarifying Questions
- Should the stories come from the most recent role, or can they come from any point in your career?
- Does the manager want a technical disagreement, a disagreement about priorities, or either?
### Part 1 — A disagreement
"Tell me about a time you disagreed with others on your team or with a partner team. How did you handle it, and what happened?"
```hint Pick one that mattered
Choose a disagreement that changed a project's outcome, and be ready to state the other side's strongest argument in its best form.
```
#### What This Part Should Cover
- The stakes, and both positions stated fairly
- How you used data, a prototype or an agreed set of criteria to resolve it, and when you escalated or committed to a decision you disagreed with
- The outcome, and the working relationship afterwards
### Part 2 — A project that failed
"Tell me about a time a project you worked on failed. What happened, what was your part in it, and what did you change afterwards?"
```hint Own your share
Choose a failure your own decisions contributed to, and think about what you do differently today because of it.
```
#### What This Part Should Cover
- Honest ownership of your share of the failure, without blaming others
- How you limited the damage once the failure was clear
- Concrete, lasting changes to your own practice or the team's
### What a Strong Answer Covers
- Stories with senior scope: impact beyond your own tasks, ambiguity, and decisions that changed a project's direction
- A clear situation, task, action and result structure, with measured impact
- Self-awareness and reflection, not only success
- Concise delivery that leaves room for the interviewer's probes
### Follow-up Questions
- Looking back, was the other side right about anything? What would you do differently?
- How did you decide when to escalate the disagreement and when to commit to a decision you disagreed with?
- How did the failure affect your team, and how did you rebuild trust with the people who depended on the project?
- Which of your projects had the largest impact beyond your own team, and what exactly was your role in it?
Overview: Senior behavioral questions about a disagreement with colleagues or a partner team and a project that failed. They test ownership, conflict resolution, reflection, and whether your stories show the cross-team scope and measured impact expected of a senior engineer.
Read the full DoorDash Software Engineer interview experience this question came from