Behavioral: A Proposal Senior Leaders Turned Down and What You Did Next

Quick Overview

A behavioral prompt for Uber product manager candidates about a proposal that senior leadership rejected. It probes ownership of the failure, how the candidate diagnosed why the pitch fell short, what they did after the meeting, and how they now build a case for executives.

Behavioral: A Proposal Senior Leaders Turned Down and What You Did Next

Company: Uber

Role: Product Manager

Category: Behavioral & Leadership

Difficulty: medium

Interview Round: Other

Describe a proposal you brought to senior leadership that they turned down. Why did it fall short, and what did you do afterward? ```hint Find the real reason Pin down the objection that actually sank the pitch, framed the way leadership saw it, and what you now do differently when you ask executives for something. ``` ### Clarifying Questions - Does it still count if leadership approved a revised version later, or should it be a proposal that stayed rejected? - Should the audience be my own executive chain, or does a cross-functional planning or budget review also count? - Can the ask be for headcount or budget, or should it be a product bet such as a new feature or market? ### What a Strong Answer Covers - A specific proposal, audience and ask, with clear stakes - A precise, owned diagnosis of why the pitch failed, rather than blaming leadership - The actions taken after the meeting: new evidence, a revised or smaller ask, or accepting the decision and committing to it - The outcome and a concrete, lasting change in how the candidate builds a case for executives ### Follow-up Questions - Looking back, was leadership's decision the right one? - How do you prepare for an executive review now? Walk me through a recent one. - If they had said no a second time, what would you have done?

Overview: A behavioral prompt for Uber product manager candidates about a proposal that senior leadership rejected. It probes ownership of the failure, how the candidate diagnosed why the pitch fell short, what they did after the meeting, and how they now build a case for executives.

Uber logo
Uber
Aug 14, 2024
mediumProduct ManagerOtherBehavioral & Leadership
0
0

Describe a proposal you brought to senior leadership that they turned down. Why did it fall short, and what did you do afterward?

Clarifying Questions Guidance

  • Does it still count if leadership approved a revised version later, or should it be a proposal that stayed rejected?
  • Should the audience be my own executive chain, or does a cross-functional planning or budget review also count?
  • Can the ask be for headcount or budget, or should it be a product bet such as a new feature or market?

What a Strong Answer Covers Guidance

  • A specific proposal, audience and ask, with clear stakes
  • A precise, owned diagnosis of why the pitch failed, rather than blaming leadership
  • The actions taken after the meeting: new evidence, a revised or smaller ask, or accepting the decision and committing to it
  • The outcome and a concrete, lasting change in how the candidate builds a case for executives

Follow-up Questions Guidance

  • Looking back, was leadership's decision the right one?
  • How do you prepare for an executive review now? Walk me through a recent one.
  • If they had said no a second time, what would you have done?